JC TeamJing ChenREALTOR® · BQ Realty · DRE #02147119

Home / Sell a Home / Comparing Offers and Negotiating as a Seller

SELLING

Comparing Offers and Negotiating as a Seller

When offers arrive, put the numbers and terms in one table before negotiating. Whether a deal closes often depends on more than the price.

Reviewed Nov 5, 2026 · By Jing Chen

What to compare

ItemQuestion
Price and netAfter credits, buyer-agent requests and costs, what do you actually keep?
FinancingCash or loan? How much down? Is there a pre-approval?
DepositHow much, and when does it reach escrow?
ContingenciesInspection, loan, appraisal, sale of the buyer's home? When are they removed?
Appraisal gapIf the appraisal is low, how much will the buyer cover?
TimingClosing date, possession, any rent-back?
Repairs and creditsAs-is, or further requests?
Cost allocationWho pays transfer tax, title, escrow and HOA charges?

Use the net proceeds calculator to compare the net on each offer. When prices are close, certainty often counts for more.

Buyer-agent compensation requests

Commissions are negotiable and there is no legal standard. After the 2024 NAR settlement, buyer-agent pay is agreed between the buyer and their agent. The California DRE explains that a buyer may ask the seller to cover some or all of it as a concession, and the seller can accept or reject. Any amount you accept belongs in your net calculation.

Common negotiating moves

  • Counteroffer: respond on price or terms. A counter generally ends the original offer, so weigh that first.
  • Multiple offers: you might ask for highest and best, or counter more than one buyer. If you do the latter, the wording must prevent two acceptances.
  • Change only what matters: focus on the one or two terms that count.
  • Backup offer: a fallback if the first buyer drops out.

Contingencies and deposits

Until contingencies are removed, a buyer can usually exit under the contract. The periods are whatever your signed contract says, so track each date. If one passes, follow the contract, for example by issuing a notice to perform.

Under Civil Code §1675, when a buyer intends to occupy a home of up to four units and the contract has a liquidated damages clause, a deposit of 3% of the price or less is generally valid, and a larger amount has to be shown reasonable. Talk to an attorney if a default occurs.

If a disclosure, or a material amendment, is delivered after the buyer signs, Civil Code §1102.3 gives the buyer time to terminate: three days after personal delivery, five after mailing or electronic delivery. That is one more reason to have disclosures ready early.

Common mistakes

  • Looking only at the top price and ignoring financing and appraisal risk.
  • Deciding on the basis of a buyer's personal letter. Details about family, ethnicity or religion raise fair housing concerns, so compare terms only.
  • Relying on verbal agreements. California real estate contracts need to be in signed writing.
  • Treating a pre-approval as an approved loan.
  • Letting a deadline push you into signing before reading everything.

Next step

Once the contract is signed, move on to seller escrow and closing. Jing Chen is a real estate agent, not an attorney or CPA, so check legal and tax effects with the right professional.

Main sources