General information only, not tax advice. Tax treatment depends on your situation; please consult a CPA or tax professional.
Why one home has several "values"
No official number tells you what your home is worth today. Pricing a sale, opening a HELOC, challenging your property tax and buying insurance all rely on different figures. Use the wrong one and you could misprice a listing or end up underinsured.
| Number | Who produces it | Best for | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| AVM (online estimate) | A computer model | A rough sense of direction | Cannot see condition, finishes or defects |
| Assessed value | County assessor | Calculating property tax | Limited by Prop 13, so it does not track the market |
| CMA | A real estate agent | Discussing list price and market conditions | An agent's opinion, not an appraisal |
| Appraisal | A licensed appraiser | Lending, legal and tax purposes | Paid, date-specific and tied to its intended use |
Where AVMs fall short
An automated valuation model estimates value from public records and sales data. Zillow itself says the Zestimate is not an appraisal and cannot replace one, calling it a free starting point. As of November 2026, it reports a nationwide median error of 7.21% for off-market homes. A median means about half of homes miss by more. On a $1.5 million house, 7% is roughly $105,000.
The blind spots are easy to picture. A model may not know whether the kitchen was redone, how the lot sits, whether the street is noisy, or whether an addition was permitted. Bay Area homes can vary widely within a single block. Averaging several sites does not fix this, because they often draw on similar data.
A federal quality control rule for AVMs took effect October 1, 2025, but it covers models used by mortgage originators and secondary market issuers. It does not mean the number on a consumer website has been validated by regulators.
Assessed value is not market value
Under Prop 13, assessed value generally rises no more than 2% a year, so long-held homes often sit well below market. That says nothing about what they would sell for. The opposite case is the useful one: if market value drops below assessed value, you can ask for a Prop 8 review. Alameda County accepts informal requests outside the formal appeal window, while Santa Clara County sets a deadline each summer.
CMAs and appraisals
A CMA compares your home with similar sold, pending and active listings nearby and adjusts for condition, and an agent can walk the property to catch what a model misses. Under California law, a licensee's opinion given in the course of their work may not be called an appraisal. When you need a formal valuation, for example for some loans, a divorce, or an estate or gift tax matter, use a licensed appraiser, and ask your attorney or CPA what is required.
If you would like to understand your home's market position, you can book a free home value consultation (a CMA discussion, not a formal appraisal). This article explains how to read one.
Keeping track over time
- Once a year, note recent sales of similar homes nearby. That tells you more than one online figure.
- Keep renovation invoices and permits, since AVMs cannot see them.
- When your assessment notice arrives around midsummer, compare it with the market and decide whether a review is worthwhile.
- Insure to rebuilding cost. Do not set coverage from market value or an AVM.
Next step
Start with why you want the number, whether for a sale, a loan, a tax review or insurance, then choose the method that fits that purpose.
Main sources
- Zillow:What is a Zestimate?(2026 年 11 月数据)
- Federal Register:Quality Control Standards for Automated Valuation Models
- FHFA:Agencies Issue Final Rule on Automated Valuation Models
- Business and Professions Code 11302(Public.Law 转载)
- California BREA:Broker Price Opinions and Other Valuation Products
- California BOE:Publication 29 California Property Tax Overview
- Santa Clara County Assessor:Informal Request for Decline in Value
- Alameda County:2026 Assessment Appeals Board Booklet
- California Department of Insurance:Residential Insurance Guide