A CMA and an appraisal are different things
A CMA (Comparative Market Analysis) is an agent's review of recent sales, active listings and details about your home. Its job is to frame a sensible range for a list price. It is not a valuation report.
An appraisal is a written professional opinion of value prepared by an appraiser. When a buyer finances a purchase, the lender usually needs one, and the borrower may be asked to pay for it. If you need a value for an estate, a divorce or a tax filing, ask your attorney or CPA what kind of report is required. A CMA is not a substitute.
| CMA discussion | Appraisal | |
|---|---|---|
| Prepared by | Real estate agent | Appraiser |
| Purpose | Discuss list price and timing | Formal opinion of value |
| Typical use | Deciding whether, when and at what price to list | Loan approval; legal or tax matters that call for one |
| Proof of value? | No | Depends on who is asking |
Why the difference matters
One house can carry several numbers at once: a website estimate, a neighbor's sale price, an agent's CMA, a buyer's appraisal. They rest on different inputs, so a gap between them doesn't mean anyone is wrong. Knowing the source tells you which number belongs at which step.
Keep in mind that a buyer's appraisal can come in below the contract price. The buyer may then ask for a reduction, cover the difference, or use a contract right to cancel. Pricing from close comparable sales gives you something concrete to discuss if that happens.
What gets reviewed
- Facts: address, property type, size, lot, age and layout.
- Condition and changes: when the roof, HVAC, kitchen or baths were updated, and whether work was permitted.
- Comparable sales: recent sales that are close in location, type, size and condition.
- Competition: what is on the market now and will be compared with your home.
- Your timing: when you need to move and whether you are also buying.
It helps to gather purchase documents, repair records, HOA materials and permit history ahead of time. The result is a price range and the reasoning behind it, not a price anyone can promise.
Using online estimates
Automated estimates come from public data and models. They can't see inside the house and may not know about a new roof. Treat one as a single data point, and don't read much into it whether it runs high or low.
Common mistakes
- Fixing on the highest sale nearby and ignoring differences in size and condition.
- Treating list prices as sale prices.
- Adding renovation costs to the price. Spending isn't always recovered dollar for dollar.
- Forgetting selling costs. The net proceeds calculator gives a rough first pass.
Next step
You can book a free home value consultation (a CMA discussion, not a formal appraisal). If you haven't decided whether to sell, the pre-listing market analysis explains what else to look at beyond price.